Go Back

Easy Pilgrim Hat Cookies for Thanksgiving (No cooking required!)

Course Cookies
Prep Time 15 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Servings 24
Author Marina


  • 1 pack Striped fudge cookies Keebler or any generic brand
  • 1 pack of refrigerated Peanut Butter Cups The small cups- Reese's or any other brand
  • Yellow icing I cheated and used a store bought Wilton tube


  1. Turn the cookies, chocolate side facing up, add a dab of icing to the larger base of the Peanut Butter Cup and gently place it on top of the cookie base.
  2. Now draw a rim to your Peanut Butter Cup's base with the icing and draw a pretty square/rectangle shaped buckle.
  3. Place your prepared Pilgrim Hat Cookies in the refrigerator till it's time for the party, that way you don't stand the risk of the chocolate melting.